Reflecting on the Westminster Confession of Faith 21-"Of Religious Worship and the Sabbath Day"


Okay, so I'm thinking through the subject of Worship as the Westminster Confession of Faith (WCF) plays it out. What is below is simply a "thinking-out-loud" chart of the three basic "Regulative Principles of Worship" in Christianity (each branch, and all sub-branches have a regulative principle, or so it seems to me; but we simply draw up the lines in different places). Give it a look, and let me know what your thoughts are:

1.      Position A (More Constricted Position):

Ÿ  True Worship-Only what is commanded in Scripture.

Ÿ  False Worship-Anything outside what is commanded in Scripture.

2.      Position B (More Lutheran, Anglican, Some Reformed, Eastern Orthodox, Roman Catholic)

Ÿ  True Worship-What is commanded (and anything not specifically forbidden is permitted and at times mandated).
Ÿ  What is prescribed by Church Councils sometimes required sometimes permitted,
Ÿ  Guided by Sacred Tradition and/or the Magisterium.

Ÿ  False Worship-Only what is specifically forbidden (more or less).

3.      Position C (What Appears to be More In-line with the WCF)

Ÿ  True Worship-What is specifically commanded in Scripture must be done,
Ÿ  What is according to the general principles of the Word is allowed,
Ÿ  Some circumstances ordered by the light of nature, Christian prudence, and also things set down by Church synods and councils for the better ordering of the public worship of God – all of which are to be governed by the rule of the Word of God (1.6 and 31.2) are permitted.

Ÿ  False Worship-That which permits or mandates what is specifically forbidden in Scripture,
Ÿ  That which neglects what is specifically commanded in Scripture,
Ÿ  That which commands [or forbids] what is permitted by the general principles of the Word etc. (this last one seems to be one of the major concerns of WCF 20.2).


But keep in mind the broad charitable recognition of WCF 25.4: “This catholic Church has been sometimes more, sometimes less visible. And particular Churches, which are members thereof, are more or less pure, according as the doctrine of the Gospel is taught and embraced, ordinances administered, and public worship performed more or less purely in them.”

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"Was America Founded as a Christian Nation?" (Rev. Ed.) by John Fea. A Review

Image
  John Fea is a professor of history at Messiah University in Mechanicsburg, PA. A university founded in 1909 by the Brethren in Christ Church. He originally published "Was America Founded as a Christian Nation? A Historical Introduction" in 2011, and it was revised in 2016. This 328-page paperback is packed full with Colonial and American history, drawing from original sources to answer that question. It is a book written "for the historically minded and thoughtful reader who is looking for help in sorting" out this question, avoiding polemics (xix). Since we live in a sound-bite culture, Fea recognizes that it is difficult to have a sustained dialogue on this topic, but he makes a valiant effort toward having that sustained dialogue. The book reads fairly straightforward, and doesn't seem to get bogged down in the contentious mudpuddles or bogs. In the end, Fea seems to get his point across. To answer the reigning question if America was founded as a Christian...
Read more

Union with Christ - An Application

Image
  (This was my weekly letter to my congregation on Wednesday, 21 February 2024) This morning in my devotional reading, I was working through 1 Corinthians 8. Though I’ve read these words a huge number of times over the years, today one verse caused me to stop and take stock.  Paul wrote, “ Thus, sinning against your brothers and wounding their conscience when it is weak, you sin against Christ ” (1 Corinthians 8:12). What struck me is a couple of things. First, in God’s saving work, we are – by grace alone – united (hitched, bonded, ingrafted) to Christ so much so, that what happens to us happens to him, and what is his becomes ours (think of Galatians 2:20, for example). As Sinclair Ferguson put it, “through union with Christ all that is his by incarnation becomes ours through faith” (“The Christian Life,” 110). Let that percolate in your heart for a while. Your fear, anxiety, tears, and so forth, he feels. And his “ Peace, be still ” is yours. Second, the way we treat one an...
Read more

"Ah, Lord! We are Animated by Anger and Anxiety, Fear and Fury..."

Image
I hesitate to put this out there because of the combative environment we are in at present. But I think some souls will take courage from this, and some will also join with me as we get to the end of this little composition. I am struck by the words of God in Zechariah 8. As he rehearses the waywardness and faithlessness of his people in the past, he clearly declares that he " set every man against his neighbor " (8:10). That got me thinking long ago. I started putting the pieces together and realized that one of God's acts of judgment is division, setting a man against his neighbor. That's what happened when he divided his people into the northern tribes and southern tribes (see 1 Kings 11:26-40). Because of Solomon's turning aside, allowing his wives to turn his heart away from the God of his father, David, the Lord brings about a rift in God's people. And this pattern of divisive judgment runs throughout Scripture. On the other hand, truthful unity is the g...
Read more